To The Point- A few questions for Dick...Yes, I watched To The Point this morning (and it wasn't nearly as painful as I thought it would be), and I have some follow-up questions for Mr. DeVos.
Mr. DeVos- You are perpetuating the myth that the state has received a "windfall" from the gasoline sales tax. But on May 13th, it was reported by the non-partisan House Fiscal Agency that there has been no growth in tax collections over last year, no "windfall" at all. In fact, your plan would have cut $285 million dollars in revenue to the schools and local cities. How would you have made up for that lost revenue had your plan been implemented?Moving on- your new TV ad states a figure on job loss that your own party discredited some time ago. Why are you still using that figure when it's been proven that it is untrue?You say your plans, that you still refuse to talk about, would cause some "painful changes" with an eye towards "long term results". Are you saying that your ideas deserve a "long term" time frame, but Granholm was supposed to instantly transform our economy? You also mention that these problems were evident at the time she took office. Would you then say that John Enlger was ineffective as a governor after 12 years in office? Do you hold him to the same standards as you do Granholm? Would you hold yourself to those same standards? And BTW, since you brought up the transition period at Amway that you claim as a success, would you care to tell us how long that took to provide positive results?You say that Granholm was "forced" into changing the SBT, but you also give her credit for trying to work on it. Is it true that the deal that was struck on the SBT last November was scuttled a week later by phone calls from you and Betsy to the Republican legislature? If not, why do you think the legislature pulled out of that deal if this issue of business tax cuts is so important? Any guesses? You also say a "majority" of the SBT will be replaced. Care to tell us exactly what programs you would cut due to lost revenue?Dick rattled off a bunch of figures on school funding. I'm not even going to touch that one, but it wouldn't surprise me if some of those were incorrect given his other statements.
He also claimed that Jobs Today had gotten "no results", but yet I could link to a whole bunch of articles that prove that isn't true. Here's
one from Friday telling of 1,111 jobs created recently right here in West Michigan. Hope someone is keeping a running total on these, I can't keep up.
It will be interesting to see if Rick tries his "gotcha" questions on Granholm next week after he let DeVos slide on the items above.